Welcome to Brewster's New Buffalo, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of New Buffalo, where inviting ambiance and exceptional flavors collide. This stylish eatery, undergoing a stunning remodel, boasts a cozy setting ideal for any dining occasion. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with warm smiles and a vibrant atmosphere, perfect for breakfast or dinner.
The menu is a delightful mix, featuring wood-fired pizzas, housemade pastas, and seasonal specials that showcase local ingredients. Standout dishes include the beloved Berry Pancakes and the savory chicken tortellini soup. Diners rave about the presentations and flavor profiles that leave a lasting impression. The addition of outdoor seating adds to its charm, making it an ideal spot during warmer months.
Whether you’re seeking a hearty breakfast or a cozy dinner, Brewster's delivers an exceptional dining experience that’s truly worth the wait!
Starters
Charcuterie Board
US$19.00Spinach And Artichoke Dip
US$13.00Sausage And Peppers
US$13.00Bruschetta
US$14.00Roasted Garlic And Chèvre Dip
US$13.00Ricotta And Honeycomb
US$14.00 Salad
House Salad
US$5.00House Salad And Soup
US$10.001/2 Chopped Salad And Soup
US$12.001/2 Specialty Salad And Soup
US$15.001/2 Rustic Steak Salad And Soup
US$15.00Brewster's Cobb
US$17.00Rustic Steak
US$17.00Specialty
US$19.00Chopped Margherita
US$14.00Caesar
US$12.00 Refreshments
Iced Tea
US$4.00Italian Sparkling Soda
US$5.00Juice
US$3.00San Pellegrino
US$4.00Dram Gingergrass
US$8.00Hop N Honey Water
US$6.00Raspberry Lemonade
US$4.00Ginger Lemonade
US$4.00Lavender Lemonade
US$6.00Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
US$6.00 Coffee Drinks
Espresso
US$5.00Latte
US$5.00Cappuccino
US$5.00Mocha
US$6.00Brewed Coffee
US$4.00Hot Tea
US$3.00Iced Glacier Cappuccino
US$6.00Lavender Tea Latte
US$6.00Hot Chocolate
US$4.00Chai Tea Latte
US$5.00Golden Latte
US$6.00Warm Hug
US$6.00Salted Caramel White
US$6.00 Entrees
Breakfast Burrito
US$10.00The Mess
US$14.00Mary's Mess
Eggs In Purgatory
US$12.00Hippie Hash
US$12.00Avocado Toast
Breakfast Blt
US$13.00Biscuits And Gravy
US$12.00Bourbon Butter Banana
US$15.00French Toast
US$12.00Mascarpone-Stuffed French Toast
US$14.00Pancakes
US$12.00Berry Pancakes
US$14.00The Old Standby
US$12.00Frittata Of The Day
US$14.00 A La Carte
Eggs
US$4.00Bacon
US$3.00Sausage
US$3.00Side Of Hippie Hash
US$8.00Side Of Potatoes
US$4.00Biscuit
US$2.00 Kids Menu-10 And Under
Scrambled Eggs
US$5.00Pancakes
US$5.00Berry Pancakes
US$7.00French Toast
US$7.00 Thin Crust Pizza
Fungi
US$18.00Bianco
US$17.00 Handhelds
Chicken Schnitzel Sammy
US$18.00Double Smash Burger
The Nightclub
US$16.00Smoked Turkey
Hand Tossed Sourdough
New Yorker
US$18.00Betty White
US$18.00Sweet And Spicy
US$20.00Pesto And Zucchini
Olive And Kessel
US$19.00 Classics
Lemon Basil Chicken
Tikka Masala
Chicken Or Shrimp Alfredo
Meatballs
Cacio E Pepe
US$13.00Roma
US$14.00Bolognese
US$15.00Shrimp And Sausage
US$17.00 Detroit Style Pizza
Triple Crown
US$27.00Build Your Own Detroit
US$23.00 Cocktails
S Shake-Up
US$13.00The Punch
Dessert
Passionfruit Cheesecake
Lemon Tres Leches
Peach Tartlet
Tiramisu
Pasta
Lemon Basil Chicken
Dessert Cocktails
Nutty By Nature
Spanglish
Espresso Martini
Chocolate Martini
Fall In N/A
After Dinner Sippers
White
Pinot Grigio
US$9.00Sauvignon Blanc
US$10.00Chardonnay
US$10.00Prosecco
US$12.00Orvieto Campogrande Classico
US$10.00Riesling
US$10.00Moscato
US$9.00Rosé
US$10.00 Pinot Grigio
Tramin
US$40.00Chloe
US$38.00Terlan
US$44.00 Chardonnay
Limestone Hill
US$49.00Toad Hollow
US$38.00Rombaeur Vineyards
US$86.00Flowers Select
US$70.00Bread And Butter
US$50.00 Sauvignon Blanc
Whitehaven
US$48.00Wapisa Sauvignon Blanc
US$40.00Kim Crawfod
US$40.00Domaine Gueneau 'Les Griottes' Sancerre
US$69.00 Other Whites
11 Minute Rose
US$46.00Nv Huber Sparkling Rosé
US$48.00Enrico Serafino Gavi
Elena Walch Pinot Bianco